Discover the Best Seafood Restaurants in Stonington Borough - Top Dining Spots

Stonington Borough, located along the picturesque Connecticut coastline, is home to some of the finest seafood restaurants in the region. Known for its charming harbor, historic buildings, and a thriving seafood industry, this small but vibrant area offers seafood lovers a range of dining experiences, from casual eateries to elegant waterfront restaurants. If you’re looking to enjoy fresh, local seafood with a view, Stonington Borough is the place to be. Among the top dining spots is BREAK WATER, a standout in the local culinary scene. Let’s dive into the best seafood restaurants you can find in this beautiful coastal town.

Why BREAK WATER Stands Out Among the Best Seafood Restaurants in Stonington Borough

Fresh, Locally Sourced Seafood

At BREAK WATER, freshness is key. The restaurant prides itself on serving locally sourced seafood, bringing the best catches from the nearby waters directly to your plate. Whether you’re in the mood for lobster, oysters, or a fresh catch of the day, BREAK WATER ensures that every dish is crafted from the highest quality ingredients, supporting local fishermen and sustainable practices.

Relaxing, Scenic Dining Experience

One of the highlights of dining in Stonington Borough is the stunning views of the water, and BREAK WATER offers an unbeatable experience. With its outdoor seating options overlooking the harbor, you can enjoy your meal while taking in the breathtaking sights of the boats and the sparkling waters. The ambiance is perfect for a romantic evening or a casual meal with friends and family.

A Menu for Every Taste

While BREAK WATER specializes in seafood, its menu is diverse enough to cater to all tastes. From classic lobster rolls and pan-seared scallops to seafood pasta and fresh salads, you’ll find dishes that highlight the bounty of the sea. Whether you’re a lifelong seafood lover or trying it for the first time, BREAK WATER offers something for everyone. The restaurant also provides a variety of non-seafood options, making it an excellent choice for groups with varying tastes.

Other Must-Try Seafood Spots in Stonington Borough

While BREAK WATER is a standout, Stonington Borough boasts several other fantastic seafood restaurants that are worth exploring.

The Dog Watch Cafe

Located along the waterfront, The Dog Watch Cafe is a popular local haunt known for its laid-back atmosphere and delicious seafood offerings. The menu features classic seafood dishes like fish and chips, clam chowder, and fried seafood platters. With a lively vibe and scenic views, it’s a great spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Their outdoor seating area is the perfect place to enjoy fresh seafood while watching the boats sail by.

Noah’s Restaurant

For those looking for a more refined dining experience, Noah’s Restaurant is a top choice. Located in nearby Stonington, this upscale restaurant offers a sophisticated seafood menu with an emphasis on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The elegant setting and exceptional service make Noah’s an ideal spot for special occasions or a romantic night out. From delicate fish dishes to rich seafood bisques, Noah’s delivers high-quality seafood with a touch of elegance.

Milagro Cafe

While not exclusively a seafood restaurant, Milagro Cafe is known for its exceptional seafood dishes with a Latin twist. Located just a short drive from Stonington Borough, Milagro Cafe offers a variety of seafood options, including tacos, ceviche, and seafood paella. The vibrant, colorful ambiance adds to the dining experience, making it a fun and exciting spot to enjoy seafood with a unique flair.

Must-Try Dishes in Stonington Borough

Lobster Roll

A visit to Stonington Borough wouldn’t be complete without trying a lobster roll, and BREAK WATER serves one of the best in the area. With fresh lobster meat tucked into a buttery, toasted roll, it’s a classic New England dish that’s perfect for a seaside meal. Whether you prefer your lobster roll with a touch of mayo or a drizzle of melted butter, this dish is a must-try for any seafood lover.

Oysters on the Half Shell

Stonington Borough is known for its local oysters, and you can enjoy some of the best at BREAK WATER and other local seafood spots. Served fresh and chilled with a squeeze of lemon or a tangy mignonette, oysters on the half shell are a perfect appetizer to start your meal. Pair them with a crisp glass of white wine for a true taste of the coast.

Seafood Pasta

If you’re looking for something hearty and flavorful, a seafood pasta dish is always a great choice. BREAK WATER offers a variety of seafood pastas, often featuring fresh shrimp, scallops, and clams tossed with pasta in a light, flavorful sauce. It’s a filling and satisfying dish that combines the rich flavors of the sea with the comforting texture of pasta.

Pan-Seared Scallops

For a lighter, more refined option, pan-seared scallops are always a hit. These tender, sweet scallops are cooked to perfection and often served with seasonal vegetables or a delicate sauce. BREAK WATER and other top seafood restaurants in Stonington Borough prepare this dish beautifully, making it a favorite among seafood enthusiasts.

FAQs About Seafood Dining in Stonington Borough

1. What is the best time to visit Stonington Borough for seafood?

The best time to visit for seafood is during the summer and fall months when local seafood is abundant. However, many restaurants, including BREAK WATER, offer fresh seafood year-round, so you can enjoy it no matter when you visit.

2. Are there vegetarian options available at BREAK WATER?

Yes, while BREAK WATER specializes in seafood, they offer a variety of non-seafood and vegetarian options on their menu. You can enjoy fresh salads, pasta dishes, and other delicious choices that cater to different dietary preferences.

3. Does BREAK WATER offer takeout?

Yes, BREAK WATER offers takeout options, so you can enjoy their delicious seafood dishes at home or on the go. Call ahead or order directly from the restaurant to pick up your meal.

4. Can I make a reservation at BREAK WATER?

Reservations are highly recommended, especially during peak dining hours. You can call BREAK WATER at 1-860-415-8123 to make a reservation and ensure a spot at this popular seafood spot.

5. Is there outdoor seating at BREAK WATER?

Yes, BREAK WATER offers outdoor seating with beautiful views of the harbor, allowing you to enjoy your meal in a scenic and relaxing environment. It’s the perfect place to savor fresh seafood while taking in the coastal ambiance.

Conclusion

If you’re a seafood lover, Stonington Borough is the ultimate destination for fresh, delicious seafood. From the casual atmosphere of The Dog Watch Cafe to the refined elegance of Noah’s Restaurant, there’s something for everyone. However, BREAK WATER stands out as one of the best seafood restaurants in Stonington Borough, offering a diverse menu, breathtaking views, and exceptional service. Whether you’re in the mood for a lobster roll, oysters on the half shell, or seafood pasta, Stonington Borough’s dining scene is sure to delight. Plan your visit today and indulge in some of the best seafood Connecticut has to offer!